Buyer's guide
The best recruitment agency alternatives for SaaS scale-ups in 2026
Nine ways to hire without paying a contingency fee on every role, compared on cost, the hiring volume each suits, and the providers worth looking at. Written for founders, Heads of Talent, VPs People and CFOs at Series A to D technology companies.
Last reviewed: By Chris Birkedale, CEO and Founder, Saiyō
The short answer
If you make five or more specialist hires a year, a contingency agency is usually the most expensive way to hire. The main alternatives are embedded headhunting, embedded recruitment (also called embedded RPO), enterprise RPO, fractional recruiters, recruiter marketplaces, sourcing sprints, executive search for leadership roles, and building in-house talent acquisition with AI sourcing tools. Choose by hiring volume, role seniority, and whether your problem is recruiter capacity or access to people who are not applying.
Disclosure. Saiyō provides two of the models on this list: embedded headhunting and sourcing sprints. We have included competitors where they are the better choice and said so plainly. No provider paid to appear. If you work at a provider listed here and something is out of date, email chris@saiyo.io and we will correct it.
First, decide which problem you have
A capacity problem.
Plenty of decent candidates, not enough recruiter hours to process them. Interviews slip, candidates go cold, hiring managers chase. More recruiters solve it.
An access problem.
The process runs fine, but the shortlist is thin, the best people in the market never appear, and senior roles stay open for months. More recruiters do not solve it. They run the same process faster.
Most alternatives to an agency add capacity. Fewer add access. Knowing which you need narrows this list quickly.
Why scale-ups look for an alternative to agencies
Contingency agencies are paid a percentage of salary only when their candidate is hired. That works for the occasional role. At volume it breaks in three ways.
- Cost compounds. UK contingency fees typically run 15 to 20% of first-year salary, 18 to 22% for technology roles, and more for scarce skills such as AI. Twenty-four hires at £75,000 at a 25% fee is £450,000 a year.
- Incentives reward speed over fit. The agency is paid on placement, so the first acceptable candidate is worth more to it than the best one.
- Nobody owns the process. Several agencies on one brief means duplicated outreach, inconsistent candidate experience and no single view of the market.
All nine alternatives at a glance
| Model | How you pay | Typical cost | Hiring volume it suits | Solves capacity or access? | Providers to look at |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Contingency agency (the baseline) | Percentage of first-year salary, on hire | 15 to 25% of salary in the UK; more for scarce skills | 1 to 4 a year | Neither, reliably | Many |
| 1. Embedded headhunting | Flat monthly subscription | Flat monthly fee; model your plan in the cost calculator | 5 to 150 a year | Access, plus capacity | Saiyō |
| 2. Embedded recruitment (embedded RPO) | Fixed monthly fee per recruiter | Rates rarely published; quoted per recruiter | Steady volume across many roles | Capacity | Talentful, Troi, Move, Amby |
| 3. Enterprise RPO | Management fee plus per-hire fees, multi-year | Quoted per programme | Hundreds a year | Capacity at scale | Cielo, WilsonHCG, PeopleScout, Resource Solutions, Allegis Global Solutions |
| 4. Fractional recruiters | Hourly, retainer or per hire | Dover reports $75 to $125 an hour on average | 2 to 8 a year | Capacity | Dover, independent recruiters |
| 5. Recruiter marketplaces | Percentage of salary, on hire | Not published; third parties report around 20 to 25% for Paraform | Urgent individual roles | Capacity, in parallel | Paraform |
| 6. Sourcing sprints (headhunted talent delivery) | Fixed sprint fee | Quoted per sprint | Spikes and new markets | Top-of-funnel access | Saiyō CVaaS |
| 7. Executive search | Retained, about one third of first-year cash, or a fixed fee | 25 to 35% of first-year total cash compensation | 1 to 3 leaders a year | Access, for one role | See our executive search comparison |
| 8. In-house talent acquisition | Salaries, tools and job advertising | A common modelling assumption is £8,000 fully loaded per hire | Steady, predictable volume | Capacity | Your own team |
| 9. AI sourcing tools and AI recruiters | Software subscription | Varies by seat and volume | Any, as a supplement | Finds names, does not secure conversations | Various |
Which model fits?
Our recommendation
Answer all four questions to see which model fits.
| Rule (first match wins) | Recommendation shown |
|---|---|
| Q2 = One senior leader | Executive search |
| Q1 = More than 150 | Enterprise RPO, with embedded headhunting for the hardest specialist roles |
| Q1 = 1 to 4 and Q4 = None | Fractional recruiter or a recruiter marketplace for the roles you have; keep one agency for genuine one-offs |
| Q1 = 1 to 4 and Q4 is not None | Your in-house team plus AI sourcing tools; a recruiter marketplace for overflow |
| Q3 = access or both, and Q1 = 5 to 30 or 31 to 150 | Embedded headhunting (Saiyō RaaS) |
| Q3 = capacity, Q1 = 5 to 30 or 31 to 150, Q2 = Mixed or junior | Embedded recruitment (embedded RPO) |
| Q3 = capacity, Q4 = A full team | Sourcing sprints (headhunted talent delivery) into your existing team |
| Any other combination | Embedded recruitment or embedded headhunting: book a 30-minute call to decide |
What it costs: one hiring plan, five ways
Worked example: 24 specialist hires in a year, average base salary £75,000.
| Route | Annual cost | Cost per hire |
|---|---|---|
| Contingency agency at 25% | £450,000 | £18,750 |
| Recruiter marketplace at 22.5% | £405,000 | £16,875 |
| In-house team at £8,000 fully loaded per hire | £192,000 | £8,000 |
| Saiyō embedded headhunting (RaaS) | See the cost calculator | See the cost calculator |
Embedded recruitment and enterprise RPO are left out of the table because providers rarely publish rates. Ask for an all-in cost per hire based on your own plan, not a monthly fee in isolation. Model your own numbers with the Saiyō cost calculator. Figures are indicative.
The nine alternatives in detail
1. Embedded headhunting
- What it is
- A trained headhunter, not a generalist recruiter, works inside your team on a flat monthly subscription. They run your process in your ATS and under your brand, including inbound, but their core job is mapping the market and approaching people who are not looking.
- How you pay
- A flat monthly subscription. No per-hire fees.
- Best for
- Scale-ups making 5 to 150 specialist Leadership, GTM or AI hires a year, where the strongest candidates are passive.
- Watch for
- It needs an internal owner and a hiring plan. For one or two hires a year, it is more than you need.
- Providers to look at
- Saiyō (our own service): embedded headhunters for technology scale-ups across the UK, Europe, North America, APAC and the Middle East. Delivery standards: a qualified shortlist in under 10 days, 94% offer acceptance on non-executive searches, a 45-day delivery guarantee and a 100-day free replacement. Partners average a 59% reduction in cost per hire on the roles Saiyō owns. Saiyō is a young firm; the track record sits with the people delivering it.
2. Embedded recruitment (embedded RPO)
- What it is
- An external recruiter, or a team, joins your company for a set period and runs hiring as an extension of your talent function. Sometimes called Recruitment-as-a-Service or an embedded talent partner.
- How you pay
- A fixed monthly fee, usually per recruiter, over a three, six or twelve-month term.
- Best for
- Companies with steady hiring across many roles whose main problem is recruiter capacity, and who want process, reporting and employer brand handled well.
- Watch for
- Most embedded recruiters are talent acquisition generalists. They add hours, not necessarily reach into passive talent. Ask how much of each shortlist is headhunted rather than inbound.
- Providers to look at
- Talentful: one of the longest-established embedded RPO providers, with offices in New York, London and Berlin. Works on a fixed monthly subscription and states its partners save almost 50% on average versus a traditional agency model.
- Troi: flexible embedded RPO delivered through a fixed, all-inclusive monthly fee, combining recruiters, process and technology.
- Move: a UK talent consultancy offering embedded recruiters on a fixed monthly fee, a sourcing engine and TA consultancy, with no placement commissions. A strong fit if you want your own TA function strengthened as well as supported.
- Amby: an embedded recruitment provider working on a monthly subscription, with a client base that includes Nordic technology companies such as Kahoot! and Whereby.
3. Enterprise RPO
- What it is
- Recruitment process outsourcing, where a provider takes over all or part of your recruitment function under a multi-year programme.
- How you pay
- Typically a management fee plus per-hire or per-unit fees, agreed per programme.
- Best for
- Large organisations hiring hundreds of people a year, often across many countries and role types.
- Watch for
- Long mobilisation, minimum volumes and contract terms built for enterprise. Most Series A to D scale-ups find it too heavy.
- Providers to look at
- Cielo, WilsonHCG, PeopleScout, Resource Solutions and Allegis Global Solutions.
4. Fractional recruiters
- What it is
- An experienced recruiter working part-time for you, by the hour, on a retainer or per hire.
- How you pay
- Hourly, a weekly or monthly retainer, or a per-hire fee.
- Best for
- Early-stage companies making a handful of hires a year without a TA team.
- Watch for
- Continuity. A fractional recruiter may be working for several companies at once, and capacity can disappear when you need it most.
- Providers to look at
- Dover: a free applicant tracking system paired with a marketplace of vetted fractional recruiters. Dover reports average hourly rates of $75 to $125 and an average cost per hire of around $4,800 across companies using its marketplace.
- Independent recruiters: many senior in-house recruiters now work fractionally. Ask for references from companies at your stage.
5. Recruiter marketplaces
- What it is
- A platform that puts your role in front of a network of independent recruiters, several of whom work it in parallel.
- How you pay
- A percentage of first-year salary when you hire, collected by the platform.
- Best for
- One or two urgent roles, especially in the US, where parallel coverage matters more than process ownership.
- Watch for
- The economics are still contingent, so at volume the costs look like an agency's. Candidate experience and employer brand sit with many different recruiters.
- Providers to look at
- Paraform: a contingency recruiter marketplace that raised a $40 million Series B in March 2026 and works with a network of more than 10,000 independent recruiters. It does not publish its fee; third-party reviews most often report 20 to 25% of first-year salary.
6. Sourcing sprints (headhunted talent delivery)
- What it is
- A headhunting team maps the market and delivers screened, interested candidates straight into your ATS for a fixed period. Your own team runs the interviews.
- How you pay
- A fixed fee per sprint.
- Best for
- Hiring spikes after a funding round, entering a new market, or giving an in-house team the top-of-funnel reach it lacks.
- Watch for
- It only works if your team has the capacity to interview and close what arrives.
- Providers to look at
- Saiyō CVaaS (our own service): full market analysis plus screened, headhunted candidates delivered into your ATS.
7. Executive search
- What it is
- A retained, exclusive search for a single leadership role, run by mapping the whole market and approaching passive leaders directly.
- How you pay
- Usually 25 to 35% of first-year total cash compensation in three instalments, or a fixed retained fee with some firms.
- Best for
- Director, VP and C-suite appointments that set direction for a function.
- Watch for
- It is the wrong tool for the team beneath the leader. Ask what happens after the appointment.
8. In-house talent acquisition
- What it is
- Employing your own recruiters, coordinators and tools.
- How you pay
- Salaries, benefits, ATS and sourcing software, and job advertising.
- Best for
- Companies with steady, predictable hiring that justifies permanent headcount.
- Watch for
- Capacity is fixed while hiring demand is not. When hiring spikes, senior and specialist roles slip first. When it slows, you carry the cost.
9. AI sourcing tools and AI recruiters
- What it is
- Software that searches profiles, ranks matches, writes outreach and schedules interviews, sometimes packaged as an autonomous "AI recruiter".
- How you pay
- A software subscription, usually per seat or per volume of outreach.
- Best for
- Making an existing recruiter faster at mapping a market and handling admin.
- Watch for
- AI finds names and sends messages. It does not headhunt. The people you most want are already flooded with automated outreach, and getting their attention still takes a credible person, a phone call and a reason to listen.
When an agency is still the right call
Agencies are not always the wrong answer. Keep one when you have a genuinely one-off role with no ongoing need, when a niche specialist agency holds a network nobody else does, or when you are hiring so rarely that any fixed cost would sit idle. The mistake is using a contingency model as your default hiring engine once you are making five or more specialist hires a year.
How to choose: five questions for any provider
- What is the all-in cost per hire on our hiring plan, not just the monthly fee?
- How much of a typical shortlist is headhunted, and how much is inbound?
- Who exactly will work on our roles, and what is their background?
- What happens if the shortlist is late or a hire leaves early? Get delivery and replacement terms in writing.
- How quickly can we scale up, scale down or exit?
Saiyō's perspective
Most alternatives to an agency fix the cost problem by fixing the commercial model. That matters, but it is half the answer. Swapping a percentage fee for a monthly fee does not change who sits in the seat or what they do all day.
The harder problem for technology scale-ups is access. AI, ATS and sourcing tools have made it easier to find names. They have not made it easier to start a real conversation with the people who are not looking. That takes a trained headhunter, and it is why Saiyō puts headhunters, not generalists, inside its partners' teams.
The best candidates don't apply. So we go and get them.